440 E Columbus Avenue Bellefontaine, OH 43311
3
Bed
2/1
Bath
0.3
Acres
$349,900
MLS# 1038242
3 BR
2/1 BA
0.3 AC
Photos
Map
Photos
Map
Sale Pending
Received 04/24/2025
More About 440 E Columbus Avenue
This stunning Colonial home is located just a short walk from the vibrant Bellefontaine Downtown and nearby parks. Meticulously maintained and full of character, this rare gem is now available as the sellers embark on a new adventure in the country.
Step inside to discover a home filled with timeless charm and thoughtful updates. You'll find beautiful wood floors, elegant wooden banisters, and one of a kind outlet covers in the living room. Unique features include glass doorknobs, a built-in wooden buffet in the dining room, a gorgeous front door with stained glass insert, more stain glass in the landing window upstairs and a painted brick fireplace.
The updated kitchen (2018) complete with a stainless-steel countertop with a connecting Butler's Pantry.
A distinctive half-bath on the main level adds even more character, while the third floor boasts knotty pine walls and has plumbing in place for a potential third bathroom.
The dining room features a built-in wooden hutch with drawers, and the lighting throughout the home is both varied and spectacular. With three finished levels, the home offers 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, with room to grow.
The spacious owner's suite is truly magazine-worthy, complete with a soaking tub, walk-in shower, double vanity, and a cozy fireplace. Enjoy a rooftop view from the master suite to an enclosed porch (located on the main level) that could be your ideal reading nook, plant haven, or craft room. Spare bedroom on 2nd level has an attached office which offers a view of the side & back yard.
Additional highlights include:
Detached 2-car garage with generous rear parking
All appliances included
Backyard playset stays
Ventless gas logs installed in 2019
New water softener in 2018,
80% of all windows have been replaced since 2018
Very Large Deck
Sellers are offering a 2-year paid home warranty through APHW.
Don't miss your chance to own this truly special home!
Connect with a loan officer to get started!
Directions to this Listing
: From Center of Bellefontaine take Columbus Ave East 4 blocks. House on right side at 440 E Columbus-Parking is in the back. Do NOT park in driveway to the west of house-that belongs to the neighbor.
Information Refreshed: 4/30/2025 10:06 PM
Property Details
MLS#:
1038242Type:
Single FamilyCounty:
LoganAge:
95Appliances:
Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Softener Owned, Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Water HeaterArchitecture:
Cape CodBasement Type:
FullConstruction:
BrickCooling:
Central Air, Window Unit(s)Heating:
Forced Air, Natural GasInside Features:
Security System, Window Coverings, Ceiling Fans, Wood FloorsLot Description:
.3010Outside:
Deck, FencedSchool District:
Bellefontaine CitySewer:
Public SewerWater:
Supplied Water
Rooms
Bathroom 1:
8x10 (Level: )Bedroom 1:
15x14 (Level: )Bedroom 3:
11x12 (Level: )Bedroom 4:
10x12 (Level: )Bedroom 5:
7x3 (Level: )Dining Room:
15x12 (Level: )Entry:
9x4 (Level: )Kitchen:
10x12 (Level: )Living Room:
26x14 (Level: )Office:
10x8 (Level: )
Online Views:
0This listing courtesy of Terri Penhorwood (937) 592-7653 , Royer Realty LLC (937) 592-7653
Explore Greater Dayton & Surrounding Area
Monthly Cost
Mortgage Calculator
*The rates & payments shown are illustrative only.
Payment displayed does not include taxes and insurance. Rates last updated on 4/24/2025 from Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey. Contact a loan officer for actual rate/payment quotes.
Payment displayed does not include taxes and insurance. Rates last updated on 4/24/2025 from Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey. Contact a loan officer for actual rate/payment quotes.
Properties Similar to 440 E Columbus Avenue

Sell with Sibcy Cline
Enter your address for a free market report on your home. Explore your home value estimate, buyer heatmap, supply-side trends, and more.
Must reads
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity programs of the Western Regional Information Systems and Technology, Inc. Those listings held by brokerage firms other than Sibcy Cline, Inc. are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by Western Regional Information Systems and Technology, Inc. Information is provided for personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2022 Western Regional Information Systems and Technology, Inc. / All Information is believed accurate, but is NOT guaranteed.